---
title: "Essay Feedback Generator: Glow and Grow Comments"
description: "Free essay feedback generator for teachers. Rate thesis, evidence, reasoning and more, then copy Glow and Grow comments with a next step for each."
canonical: https://formswrite.com/tools/essay-feedback-generator
last-updated: 2026-10-18
---

Free essay feedback generator

# Essay Feedback Generator

Rate each part of an essay, from the thesis to conventions, and this free generator writes feedback to the student with a clear next step for every growth area, as Glow and Grow, Two stars and a wish, a paragraph or a line per criterion. It runs in your browser with no sign-up; to draft feedback from the essay text itself, use the AI essay grader.

[Write feedback](#generator)[Draft it from the essay with AI](/accounts/signup?source=essay-feedback-generator&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)

-   Free, no sign-up
-   5 essay types, 3 tones, 4 formats
-   A next step for every grow

## Your feedback

Shuffle wording

### Glow and Grow

Copy

Glow - Great work here: You state your claim early and return to it in every paragraph, so the essay never drifts. - This is a real strength: You include relevant evidence for most of your points. Grow - There is no counterargument, so the essay does not show why a reader should reject the other side. One thing to work on: Add a paragraph that states the strongest opposing view fairly, then answers it with evidence. - Your explanations repeat the evidence in other words instead of analyzing it. Your next step: Add a sentence that links each paragraph back to your claim.

577 characters

## What makes essay feedback useful

Students act on feedback that is specific, limited and forward-looking. Specific means it points to the part of the essay it is about, ideally a paragraph or a sentence. Limited means two or three comments, not twelve: a student who gets every problem at once fixes the easiest ones, usually commas. Forward-looking means each growth comment ends with what to do next, not only what went wrong.

That is why the generator orders growth comments by importance: a missing thesis comes before weak evidence, and evidence comes before conventions. Fix the argument first and the rest is easier to see.

## An example

For a ninth grade argumentative essay with a strong claim, evidence on track and commentary that needs work, the encouraging Glow and Grow version reads like this:

-   **Glow:** Your claim is precise and arguable, and it sets up the whole essay.
-   **Grow:** Your evidence is followed by summary rather than explanation of how it supports your claim. Your next step: after each piece of evidence, add two sentences that explain how it proves your claim.

## Rating each criterion

-   **A strength:** the student could teach this to a classmate.
-   **On track:** meets the expectation, with small things to polish.
-   **Needs work:** present, but not yet doing its job in the essay.
-   **Missing:** not in the essay yet.

If you grade with a rubric, map its levels to these four and the feedback will line up with the score. The [rubric library](/rubrics) explains the AP and classroom rubrics row by row, and the [essay feedback comments bank](/blog/essay-feedback-comments) has more wording for every criterion.

## From ratings to the essay itself

This tool saves typing, but you still read each essay and decide the ratings. The [Formswrite AI essay grader](/ai-essay-grader) reads the essay against your rubric, suggests a level for every criterion with the sentences that justify it, and drafts glow and grow feedback in the tone you pick. You edit and approve each essay before a student sees anything. Every account grades 5 essays a month for free; Pro ($19 a month or $49.99 a year) covers up to 400.

## Feedback and grading tools

-   [AI Essay GraderFeedback and rubric scores drafted from each essay, with quotes as evidence.](/ai-essay-grader)
-   [Essay feedback commentsA bank of comments by criterion and level, with examples.](/blog/essay-feedback-comments)
-   [Rubric libraryAP and classroom rubrics explained row by row.](/rubrics)
-   [Report card comment generatorPersonalized report card comments within your character limit.](/tools/report-card-comment-generator)

## Essay feedback generator FAQ

How does the essay feedback generator work?

Pick the essay type and grade level, rate each part of the essay (a strength, on track, needs work or missing) and choose a tone and a format. The generator writes feedback addressed to the student, with a concrete next step for every growth area, from a bank of comments written by teachers and editors.

Does it read the essay?

No. This free tool works from your ratings, not the essay text, and runs entirely in your browser. To get feedback drafted from the essay itself, with quotes from the student’s writing behind every comment, use the Formswrite AI essay grader: 5 essays a month are free and you approve every comment before a student sees it.

What is Glow and Grow feedback?

Glow and Grow is a feedback format with two parts: what the student did well (glow) and what to work on next (grow). It works because it is short and specific, and each grow names a next step the student can act on in the next draft.

What is Two stars and a wish?

Two stars and a wish names two things that worked and one thing to improve. The generator picks the strongest criteria for the stars and the most important growth area for the wish, putting higher-order concerns such as the thesis and evidence before conventions.

Can I point to a specific paragraph or sentence?

Yes. Choose the criterion, then add a paragraph number, a short quote from the essay, or both. They are added to the comment about that criterion, for example “Look again at ‘the city must act now’ in paragraph 3.”

Which tone should I pick?

Encouraging suits drafts and younger writers, neutral suits most assignments, and direct suits final drafts or students who asked for blunt feedback. The same three tones are available in the Formswrite AI essay grader.

Is it free?

Yes, with no account and no limit. Nothing you type is sent to Formswrite or to an AI model.

Last reviewed October 18, 2026 by the Formswrite team, against the generator on this page.

## Let the grader read the essays

Rubric scores and glow and grow feedback drafted from every essay in a class set, approved by you. 5 essays a month are free.

[Grade essays free](/accounts/signup?source=essay-feedback-generator&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)[See the essay grader](/ai-essay-grader)
