---
title: "STAAR Writing Rubric: The 5-Point ECR Essay Rubric"
description: "The STAAR writing rubric for the extended constructed response: organization and development (3) plus conventions (2), how scoring works and examples."
canonical: https://formswrite.com/rubrics/staar-writing-rubric
last-updated: 2026-10-18
---

Texas state test rubric

# STAAR Writing Rubric for the ECR Essay

The STAAR essay, the extended constructed response, is scored on a 5-point rubric: up to 3 points for organization and development of ideas and up to 2 for conventions. Two scorers rate each essay and their scores are added for a total of up to 10; this page explains each trait, the paired-passage evidence rule and how to practice against it.

[Grade STAAR essays with this rubric](/accounts/signup?source=staar-writing-rubric&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew%3Frubric%3Dstaar-ecr)[See both modes](#modes)

-   5 points, 2 traits
-   Grades 3 to English II
-   From TEA’s 2026 scoring guides

## The 5-point rubric at a glance

The same two traits score informational and argumentative essays.

STAAR extended constructed response rubric (paraphrased)

| Criterion | Points | What earns it |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Organization and Development of Ideas | 0-3 | A clear controlling idea or thesis kept in focus, a purposeful structure with an introduction and conclusion, specific text-based evidence that is explained, and clear, purposeful word choice. Each level down weakens one or more of these. |
| Conventions | 0-2 | Consistent command of grade-level sentence construction, punctuation, capitalization, grammar and spelling. 2 allows a few errors that do not affect clarity; 1 means several errors the reader can still follow. |
| Total: 5 points per scorer, up to 10 with two scorers |  |  |

Trait names follow TEA's rubric; descriptions are our paraphrase of the 2026 scoring guides. A 0 in organization and development means a 0 in conventions.

## Organization and development of ideas (3 points)

TEA describes each level with four parts. In plain words, a 3 has all four, and each lower level weakens them:

-   **Controlling idea or thesis:** clear and fully developed at 3, present but only partly developed at 2, evident but not developed at 1.
-   **Organization:** a purposeful structure with an effective introduction and conclusion and logical connections at 3; an introduction and conclusion that do not always support the idea at 2; little visible structure at 1.
-   **Evidence:** specific, relevant, well chosen and clearly explained at 3; limited, under-explained or partly irrelevant at 2; little, extraneous or repetitive at 1.
-   **Expression of ideas:** specific, purposeful word choice at 3; general or imprecise at 2; vague and often ineffective at 1.

A 0 has no introduction and conclusion, no visible structure, and no relevant evidence, even if a controlling idea can be found.

### Evidence: explained vs dropped in (ours)

Does not earn it

-   > “The article says gardens have tomatoes, peppers and beans. It also says they are on empty lots.”
    
    Lists details from the text without explaining how they support the controlling idea.
    

Earns the point

-   > “Because the garden was built on an empty lot, the article explains, a place that once collected trash became somewhere neighbors wanted to spend time. That change is why the author calls gardens a way to reclaim a block.”
    
    Uses a specific detail and explains how it supports the idea, which is what the top evidence level asks for.
    

## Conventions (2 points)

Conventions covers sentence construction, punctuation, capitalization, grammar and spelling at grade level. A 2 shows consistent command with a few errors that do not affect clarity, a 1 shows inconsistent command with several errors, and a 0 has so many errors that the reader struggles to understand. Remember the rule: an essay that earns 0 in development earns 0 here too.

## Informational and argumentative essays

Same rubric, different job for the thesis. Prompts and paragraphs below are ours.

InformationalArgumentative

The informational essay explains an idea from the passage or passages. The controlling idea is a statement of what the essay will explain, and the evidence is details from the text that develop it.

**A prompt in the usual style (ours):** “Read the two articles about community gardens. Write an informational essay explaining how community gardens benefit a neighborhood. Use evidence from both articles.”

**A paragraph that works (ours):** “Community gardens also bring neighbors together. The first article describes a garden in El Paso where families who had never met now share tools and recipes. The second adds that gardens give older residents a reason to be outside and talking with young people. Both show that a garden grows relationships as well as vegetables.” Evidence comes from both texts and is explained in the last sentence.

The argumentative essay takes a position on a question raised by the passages and supports it with text evidence. The thesis is the position, and each paragraph gives a reason backed by details from the reading.

**A prompt in the usual style (ours):** “Should cities replace parking lots with parks? Write an argumentative essay stating your position, using evidence from both selections.”

**A thesis that works (ours):** “Cities should turn some parking lots into parks, because parks cool neighborhoods in summer and give people a free place to exercise.” It is a clear position with two reasons the essay can develop.

## Paired passages and evidence

In grades 6 through English II, many essays respond to two passages. The evidence part of the rubric then counts texts: evidence from both texts for a 3, from at least one for a 2, and from only one at the 1 level. Teach students to plan one detail from each passage per body paragraph.

## Common mistakes that cost points

-   Writing a summary of the passage instead of developing a controlling idea or position.
-   Using evidence from only one of two paired passages.
-   Quoting without a sentence that explains what the quote shows.
-   Writing in the wrong mode, for example arguing when the prompt asks for an informational essay.
-   Skipping the introduction or conclusion under time pressure.

## STAAR after 2027

House Bill 8, passed in 2025, replaces the end-of-year STAAR with three shorter tests during the year, starting in the 2027-28 school year. STAAR and its essay rubric still apply to 2026-27 testing. We review this page against TEA's scoring guides and will update it when rubrics for the new tests are published.

## Grading practice essays faster

The Formswrite library rubric uses the single scorer scale (5 points). The [AI essay grader](/ai-essay-grader) suggests a score for each trait with the sentences behind it and drafts feedback you edit and approve before students see it. For class writing outside test prep, see the [essay rubric templates](/rubrics/essay-rubric) and the [argumentative essay rubric](/rubrics/argumentative-essay-rubric), or bring your own to the [rubric grader](/rubric-grader). More in the [rubric library](/rubrics).

## Keep going

-   [Essay rubric templatesInformative, argumentative, narrative and more for class use.](/rubrics/essay-rubric)
-   [Argumentative essay rubricA 4-level classroom rubric for argument writing.](/rubrics/argumentative-essay-rubric)
-   [AI Essay GraderGrade practice essays on any rubric and approve every score.](/ai-essay-grader)
-   [All rubricsAP, state test and classroom rubrics explained.](/rubrics)

## STAAR writing rubric FAQ

How is the STAAR essay scored?

The STAAR reading language arts essay, called the extended constructed response, is scored on a 5-point rubric: up to 3 points for organization and development of ideas and up to 2 for conventions. TEA’s scoring guide says each essay is scored by two scorers and the scores are added, so a student can receive up to 10 points.

What happens if the essay gets a 0 for development?

If a response earns 0 in organization and development of ideas, it also earns 0 in conventions. An essay that does not answer the prompt or shows no organization cannot pick up conventions points on its own.

Which grades write a STAAR essay?

Since the 2022-23 school year, the STAAR reading language arts tests include an extended constructed response at every grade, from grade 3 through English II. Students write in response to a reading selection, in one of two modes named in the prompt: informational or argumentative.

Do students need evidence from both passages?

For paired passages in grades 6 through English II, yes for the top score. TEA’s rubric ties evidence from both texts to 3 points, evidence from at least one text to 2 points, and evidence from only one text to 1 point.

What are STAAR short constructed responses?

Besides the essay, the tests include short constructed responses. In the reading domain they are scored on a 2-point rubric written for each question; in the writing domain they use a 1-point rubric. This page covers the essay rubric.

Is STAAR being replaced?

Texas passed House Bill 8 in 2025, which replaces the end-of-year STAAR with three shorter tests across the year starting in the 2027-28 school year. STAAR and this essay rubric still apply in 2026-27. We will update this page when TEA publishes rubrics for the new tests.

Can I grade STAAR practice essays with AI?

Yes. The STAAR extended constructed response rubric is in the Formswrite library on the single scorer scale (5 points). Add your students’ practice essays as text, files, Google Docs links or phone photos of handwritten pages, review the suggested score for each trait and approve it. Double the total to compare with a two-scorer score out of 10.

## Sources and review

Last reviewed October 18, 2026 by the Formswrite team. Trait names and point values come from TEA's scoring guides; descriptions, prompts and examples are our own.

-   [2026 STAAR English II Constructed-Response Scoring Guide (TEA, PDF) (opens in a new tab)](https://tea.texas.gov/data-reports/staar/released-test-questions/2026-staar-english-ii-scoring-guide.pdf)
-   [2026 STAAR Grade 5 RLA Scoring Guide (TEA, PDF) (opens in a new tab)](https://tea.texas.gov/data-reports/staar/released-test-questions/2026-staar-5-rla-scoring-guide.pdf)
-   [2026 STAAR Grade 3 RLA Scoring Guide (TEA, PDF) (opens in a new tab)](https://tea.texas.gov/data-reports/staar/released-test-questions/2026-staar-3-rla-scoring-guide.pdf)

## Grade STAAR practice essays with this rubric

Open the grader with the STAAR extended constructed response rubric loaded, add the essays and review every suggested score.

[Grade with this rubric](/accounts/signup?source=staar-writing-rubric&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew%3Frubric%3Dstaar-ecr)[See pricing](/pricing)
