---
title: "Formswrite vs CoGrader: AI Essay Graders Compared"
description: "Formswrite vs CoGrader side by side: price, free limits, handwriting, rubrics, LMS sync, exports and privacy, and when each AI essay grader is the better pick."
canonical: https://formswrite.com/compare/formswrite-vs-cograder
last-updated: 2026-10-18
---

Formswrite vs CoGrader

# Formswrite vs CoGrader

Formswrite and CoGrader both grade essays against a rubric one criterion at a time and wait for the teacher to approve every score. CoGrader leads on LMS sync, school admin features and published accuracy data; Formswrite costs $49.99 a year instead of $180, quotes the evidence behind each score, shows how closely it matches your own grading and includes quiz and Google Forms tools.

[Try Formswrite free](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)[Other CoGrader alternatives](/compare/cograder-alternatives)

-   5 free essays a month
-   $49.99 a year
-   Facts checked October 18, 2026

## Side by side

From each product's own pages. Where Formswrite is behind, the table says so.

Formswrite vs CoGrader (October 2026)

|  | Formswrite | CoGrader |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Free plan | 5 essays a month | 150 submissions a month (Starter) |
| Paid plan for one teacher | $19 a month or $49.99 a year, up to 400 essays a month (fair use) | $19 a month, or $15 a month billed yearly ($180), 350 submissions a month |
| Schools and districts | A School plan for several teachers | Quote, unlimited submissions, admin controls |
| Typed essays in | Paste, Word, PDF and text files (one PDF per class can be split), Google Docs links, Google Classroom and Google Forms imports | File upload and LMS import |
| Handwritten essays | Yes: phone photos (one capture per student, pages kept together, QR handoff from laptop) or scanned PDFs, with unclear words highlighted and page images beside the transcription | Yes: phone photos, scans and LMS images, sorted by student |
| Rubrics | Verified library (AP History, AP Lang, AP Lit, AP Gov, AP Seminar, ACT, STAAR, NY Regents, Smarter Balanced, WIDA, IELTS and classroom rubrics) plus your own, pasted or uploaded | 500+ state-aligned rubrics (STAAR, B.E.S.T., Regents, AP, IB) plus your own |
| Calibration to your grading | Mark 3 to 5 graded essays as examples; a visible "matches you N% within 1 point" score, per-criterion stricter or more generous offsets, regrade the rest | Not checked on its public pages |
| Second grade on unsure essays | A second model grades low-confidence essays independently and flags disagreements; "Get a second opinion" on any essay | Not checked on its public pages |
| Per-criterion evidence | Quoted sentences behind every criterion score, highlighted in the essay | Scores and feedback per rubric criterion |
| Feedback | Glow and grow plus per-criterion comments, tone and length you choose, in English, Spanish, French, Portuguese, German, Filipino, Indonesian or Hindi | Glow and Grow, in the language of the submission |
| Teacher review | Nothing reaches students until you approve; unsure essays are flagged | Teachers review and approve every score before release |
| Google Classroom, Canvas, Schoology | Google Classroom import; grades go back for assignments created from Formswrite (a Classroom API limit), CSV otherwise. No Canvas or Schoology sync | Two-way sync (its FAQ says Canvas and Schoology are for school accounts) |
| Exports | Per-criterion CSV, PDF feedback sheets, private student links, class averages | Grades pushed to the LMS, gradebook CSV, class dashboard |
| AI writing and plagiarism flags | Not offered | On paid plans |
| Accuracy evidence | Our agreement study is in progress; no figure published yet | Published STAAR study (its claim: 98.5% within one point of TEA raters on 600 responses) |
| Privacy | Student names removed before the AI call; provider set to deny data collection | States FERPA, COPPA, SOC 2 Type 1; de-identified work sent to AI |
| Also included | Quiz conversion from documents, Google Forms export, worksheets and the rest of Formswrite Pro | Grading only |

Facts checked October 18, 2026 on formswrite.com, cograder.com and cograder.com/pricing.

## Where CoGrader is ahead

-   **LMS grade sync.** Two-way sync with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology; grades and feedback go back without a CSV. Formswrite has no Canvas or Schoology sync and sends grades to Classroom only for assignments it created.
-   **Handwriting from the LMS.** Both read phone photos and scans; CoGrader also reads images students turn in through the LMS and sorts a mixed stack by student.
-   **Rubric count.** More than 500 state-aligned rubrics, including Florida B.E.S.T., which our library does not cover yet.
-   **Published accuracy data.** A study on 600 Texas STAAR responses scored by official raters.
-   **School administration.** Shared rubric libraries, admin controls and AI writing and plagiarism flags.
-   **Bigger free plan.** 150 submissions a month against our 5.

## Where Formswrite is ahead

-   **Price over a year.** $49.99 a year for up to 400 essays a month, against $180 a year for 350.
-   **Evidence you can check.** Every criterion score comes with the sentences from the essay that justify it, so checking a grade takes seconds.
-   **Calibration you can see.** Mark a few graded essays as examples and the grader shows how often it matches you within 1 point, where it runs stricter or more generous, and regrades the rest with your grading. Unsure essays get a second, independent grade.
-   **AP rubrics with sources.** Our [rubric pages](/rubrics) explain each College Board, ACT and TEA rubric row by row and link to the official guidelines, and each one opens in the grader with one click.
-   **Names removed first.** Student names are stripped before the essay reaches the AI model.
-   **More than grading.** Pro also converts documents into quizzes, exports to Google Forms and includes the rest of Formswrite.

## Which one to pick

Pick **CoGrader** if grades must flow back into Canvas, Schoology or existing Classroom assignments without a file, or if your school is buying for many teachers with admin controls. Pick **Formswrite** if you want to pay $49.99 a year, want to see how closely the grader matches your own scores, teach AP and want the official rubric rows explained and preloaded, or already use Formswrite for quizzes and Google Forms. Both read handwritten essays. Many teachers can test both on the free plans in one evening.

## What Formswrite does not do

No Canvas or Schoology sync and no AI-writing or plagiarism flags. See how the [Google Classroom import](/integrations/google-classroom-ai-grading) and [handwritten essay grading](/grade-handwritten-essays) work before you switch.

## Try Formswrite with a CoGrader rubric

Bring the rubric and essays you already have and compare the scores on the same class set.

1.  Nova
    
    ### Copy your rubric
    
    Paste it as text, or upload it as a Word or PDF file. The grader turns it into criteria, levels and points you can check.
    
    [Start free Copy your rubric](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)
    
2.  Momo
    
    ### Add the same essays
    
    Paste them, upload one file per student or one class PDF, add Google Docs links, photograph handwritten pages or import from Google Classroom.
    
    [Start free Add the same essays](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)
    
3.  Kiki
    
    ### Compare the scores
    
    Read the quoted evidence where the two tools disagree. Usually the rubric wording explains it.
    
    [Start free Compare the scores](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)
    
4.  Pip
    
    ### Approve and export
    
    Approve each grade, then export a CSV or PDF feedback sheets, or share a private link with each student.
    
    [Start free Approve and export](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)
    

## Keep comparing

-   [CoGrader alternativesSeven other options, with prices and limits.](/compare/cograder-alternatives)
-   [AI Essay GraderHow the Formswrite grader works, step by step.](/ai-essay-grader)
-   [Rubric libraryAP, state test and classroom rubrics explained, with sources.](/rubrics)
-   [Best AI essay gradersThe essay graders ranked, and how to test one.](/blog/best-ai-essay-graders)

## Formswrite vs CoGrader FAQ

Is Formswrite or CoGrader better for grading essays?

Both score essays against a rubric criterion by criterion, read handwritten essays and keep the teacher in charge of every grade. CoGrader is the better pick if you need Canvas or Schoology sync, two-way sync for assignments made in Classroom, or school admin controls. Formswrite is the better pick if you want the lowest yearly price, quoted evidence behind each criterion score, calibration with a visible agreement score, AP rubric pages with official sources, and quiz and Google Forms tools in the same plan.

Which is cheaper, Formswrite or CoGrader?

For one teacher billed yearly, Formswrite Pro is $49.99 a year with up to 400 essays a month, and CoGrader Individual is $15 a month billed yearly ($180) for 350 submissions. Billed monthly both are $19. CoGrader's free plan is bigger: 150 submissions a month against 5.

Does Formswrite grade handwritten essays like CoGrader?

Yes, both do. In Formswrite you photograph each student’s pages with your phone or upload a scanned PDF; the grader transcribes them, highlights words it could not read for sure and shows the page images beside the text for you to check. CoGrader also reads phone photos, scans and LMS images and sorts them by student.

Does Formswrite sync with Google Classroom?

It imports turned-in work from a Classroom assignment. Grades go back to Classroom only for assignments created from Formswrite, because the Classroom API accepts grades only from the app that created the assignment; for others you download the CSV. Apps cannot add Classroom comments, so students get a private feedback link. CoGrader advertises two-way sync with Google Classroom, Canvas and Schoology.

Can I use the same rubric in both?

Yes. Both accept your own rubric. In Formswrite you paste or upload it and the grader turns it into criteria, levels and points you can check, or you start from a library rubric such as the AP History DBQ or the ACT Writing rubric.

How accurate is each tool?

CoGrader has published a study on Texas STAAR responses (its own claim: 98.5 percent of scores within one point of official raters). Formswrite is running an agreement study against officially scored samples and will publish it before quoting any figure. Either way, compare a few essays against your own scores before you rely on a tool.

Last reviewed October 18, 2026 by the Formswrite team, against the live Formswrite grader and CoGrader's public pages.

## Grade your next class set with Formswrite

5 essays a month are free, with every library rubric and your own. You approve every grade.

[Grade essays free](/accounts/signup?source=formswrite-vs-cograder&returnUrl=%2Fdashboard%2Fgrader%2Fnew)[See pricing](/pricing)
