Evidence for every score
Each criterion gets a level, points and the exact sentences from the essay that justify them, highlighted in the essay.
Formswrite's AI essay grader scores each essay against your rubric one criterion at a time and quotes the sentences behind every score. You review, edit and approve each grade before a student sees it, and the first 5 essays every month are free.
Argumentative essay
Student 14
14 / 16
Evidence for Evidence
“The city's own 2023 survey found that 62 percent of riders would take the bus more often if it came every ten minutes.”
GlowYour claim is precise and you return to it in every paragraph.
GrowExplain why the survey supports your claim, not only what it says.
One assignment, one rubric, the whole class set. Most of your time goes to reviewing, not to the first read.
Give it a title, the grade level and the prompt, and add any source texts the students wrote from, so the grader knows what was asked.
Choose a verified rubric (AP DBQ, LEQ, AP Lang, AP Lit and more), paste or upload your own, or generate one. Check the criteria and points before you grade.
Paste text, upload one Word, PDF or text file per student (or one PDF for the whole class), add Google Docs links, photograph handwritten pages, or import from Google Classroom or Google Forms.
Each essay comes back with a level, points, quoted evidence and a reason per criterion, plus glow and grow feedback. Edit anything, regrade one criterion, then approve.
The grader shows its work, so checking a score takes seconds instead of a second full read.
Each criterion gets a level, points and the exact sentences from the essay that justify them, highlighted in the essay.
What the student did well and the next step to improve, in a tone you choose: encouraging, neutral or direct, short or detailed.
Essays the grader is unsure about get a second, independent grade from another model; disagreements are flagged "please review", so your attention goes where it is needed.
Student names are stripped before the essay reaches the AI model, and nothing is shared with students until you approve.
Average score per criterion and the students who need reteaching on each one, ready for tomorrow’s lesson.
A CSV with one column per criterion, PDF feedback sheets per student or for the class, or a private feedback link.
Typed, handwritten, or straight from Google Classroom and Google Forms.
Paste essays one by one, or upload Word (.docx), PDF or text files, one per student. The student name comes from the file name or the first line. One PDF with the whole class can be split by student.
Paste the links to students’ Google Docs and the grader reads each essay.
Photograph the pages with your phone or upload a scanned PDF. You check the transcription, with unclear words highlighted and the page images alongside, before you approve.
Import turned-in work from a Classroom assignment, or the paragraph answers of a Google Form or a Formswrite form. Results go out as a CSV or Google Sheet, and back to Classroom when the assignment was created from Formswrite.
A general chatbot can comment on one essay. A grader is built for the class set.
| Formswrite grader | General chatbot | |
|---|---|---|
| Grades a whole class set in one batch | Yes | No |
| Same rubric applied to every essay automatically | Yes | No |
| Student names removed before the AI sees the essay | Yes | No |
| Nothing reaches students until you approve | Yes | No |
| Per-criterion scores in a gradebook CSV | Yes | No |
| Class averages per criterion | Yes | No |
An AI essay grader is good at the slow, repetitive part of grading: reading every essay against the same criteria, finding the thesis, checking whether evidence is specific, and drafting a comment for each row of the rubric. It stays as consistent on the thirtieth essay as on the first. It is weaker on voice, humor, unusual structures and arguments that only work in context, which is why the Formswrite grader never finalizes a grade on its own and flags essays it is unsure about.
The quality of the result depends mostly on the rubric. “Uses at least two specific pieces of evidence that support the claim” grades well; “shows deep understanding” does not. If you are writing a rubric from scratch, the rubric generator drafts observable criteria you can edit, and the rubric library explains the AP rubrics row by row.
Every Formswrite account grades 5 essays a month for free. That is enough to compare the grader with your own scores on a real assignment before you rely on it. Pro costs $19 a month or $49.99 a year (about $4.17 a month) and raises the allowance to about 400 essays a month under a fair use limit. The grader, the rubric library and the exports are the same on both plans.
We are measuring agreement between the grader and officially scored sample essays and will publish that study, with its method, before quoting any accuracy figure. Our earlier guide on whether AI can grade essays covers where AI grading is reliable and where it is not.
For AP teachers the library includes the College Board rubric rows for the DBQ, LEQ, the three AP Lang essays and the three AP Lit essays, each linked to its official source. The dedicated AP History essay grader and AP Lang essay grader pages explain how those essays are scored. The library also has the SAQ, AP Seminar IWA and AP Gov argument essay rubrics, the ACT writing and STAAR rubrics, and classroom rubrics for argumentative, narrative, informative and expository writing. Any rubric you paste works the same way.
Writing the comments yourself? The free essay feedback generator builds glow and grow comments per criterion, and the report card comment generator does the same for end-of-term reports. Comparing tools? See Formswrite vs CoGrader and our best AI essay graders roundup.
Grade or correct three to five essays yourself and mark them “use as example”. The grader uses them as anchors for the rest of the class set, shows how often it matches you within 1 point, and tells you per criterion whether it runs stricter or more generous than you. One click regrades the remaining essays with your grading. When an essay is borderline, a second model grades it independently and any disagreement lands in your review queue; you can also ask for a second opinion on any essay.
Paper essays work too: photograph handwritten essays with your phone or upload a scanned PDF, then check the transcription with the page images beside it. The Google Classroom import brings in turned-in work from an assignment; grades go back to Classroom for assignments created from Formswrite (a Classroom limit), and students get a private feedback link because Classroom has no comments for apps. The Google Forms import grades paragraph answers and exports a CSV or Google Sheet, since Google Forms cannot take grades back.
Feedback can be written in English, Spanish, French, Portuguese, German, Filipino, Indonesian or Hindi, set per assignment. Read it before you approve, as you would in English.
Canvas and Schoology sync, and AI-writing or plagiarism detection, are not part of the grader. More answers are in the AI grading FAQ.
Start free with 5 essays a month. Pro is $19 a month or $49.99 a year (about $4.17 a month).
$0
No credit card
$49.99 /year
or $19 /month. Cancel or pause anytime.
Last reviewed by the Formswrite team, against the live product.
Pick a rubric, add the essays, review the drafts and approve. 5 essays a month are free.